ANOTHER PATH
Paula J. Coffer
All of us want to be happy. We want to have a
really great relationship and we want to have the opportunity to love and be
loved. Truthfully, nothing else really matters. What goes into building a great
relationship? Isn’t self—acceptance the first ingredient? For most of us that
degree of self-acceptance necessary for a desired relationship with someone is
pretty much a given. We just “are” and therefore don’t think about it. Okay, so
an obese person or a person with scars from an accident or a person with some
sort of physical deformity has to overcome a lot of self-hatred that has been
learned from others before self- acceptance is a reality. But, if you basically
look “normal” on the outside and for all intents and purposes are a normal
everyday person, what if within you there is such a raging storm that
self-acceptance is far from being a given. What if that storm never really
calms completely and having that successful relationship is just a dream?
Mine
is a story about facing the raging storm within and how I’ve attempted to calm
the waves enough to enjoy a relationship; a relationship with myself as much as
with another.
DECADE 1 (YEARS 0-10)
Growing up in the desert Southwest had its unique qualities. Grass, for an
example, was a luxury that most of us didn’t have because the water bills would
have been too high. So that meant playing in the dirt or in
some other
makeshift play area. For example, we had this large tractor tire lying in the
backyard. It was filled with sand in the middle and we could sit on the tire
and wiggle our toes down into the cool damp sand. What a wonderful place to sit
and share tea and conversation. We’d look at magazines and just know what we
would wear and do. We were so big! Even if we were only
three.
Pricilla,
Chris, and I would play for hours in the backyard together. We were okay with
playing house together. We had that portion of the yard with the tire set aside
where our brothers weren’t allowed because they kept stepping on the tablecloth
or messing up the rocks we used for room dividers. Pricilla and I were only
three years old and really had no cares in the world. We just played with our
dolls and tea sets and enjoyed life together. Suddenly, the neighbor put a
fence up. Not just any fence, but a privacy fence. Now Chris couldn’t come over
any time he wanted. We all cried when Chris’s mother told us that Chris had to
play in their own yard and couldn’t come over anymore. We could still look
through the cracks in the fence, though, and talk with each other. Chris’s
mother began to dress him in the cutest dresses and shoes. Oh how I wished my
parents could afford to buy me dresses and shoes like his. So for the next year
and a half or so, Pricilla, Chris, and I would play apart and talk through the
fence. This period of my life was pure innocence, joy, and a pure love of life.
No responsibilities, no worries, no concerns, just the love of a friend,
family, and of myself.
A
turning point for me was when my father accepted a job in
I
still held on to too much of my innocence. I learned that boys were expected to
play in the dirt and get all grungy. I learned that boys
were expected to be tough, to not cry, to want to push
others around, to play rough and tough. I learned those things and kind of did
some of them. But I didn’t enjoy being the best at everything. I didn’t enjoy
making someone feel bad because he or she couldn’t do something as well as
someone else. It was this spirit of aggressive competitiveness that I disliked
most about being a boy.
Most
important, I learned to be secretive and for the first time I learned what
rejection was. Unfortunately, the lesson was from my own family. But I also
learned that I could overcome this rejection, and I could overcome my sense of
loneliness. Within me I had the strength to endure the silence. Within me I had
the strength to keep my innermost feelings to myself, but I so wanted to be
able to talk to someone. There were just so many questions, so many things I
wanted to know. Like why am I this way, my two brothers aren’t, nor any male
figure in my life. There’s something wrong with me.
What
was it about me that kept me gravitating toward beautiful girls who wanted to
be my friend? Gloria Jean was just such a person. We would play and talk and
walk together. We even started the first grade together. I even kissed her! She
was everything that I saw myself as being. Really, it took a little while
before I realized that she and I were very different people. My mother would
give us three boys a burr haircut each summer and then let it grow some during
the school year. Gloria Jean didn’t get the haircut; her hair was allowed to be
long and flowing. How I wanted hair like hers! She got to wear the most
beautiful dresses and Mary Jane shoes to school; I had to wear pants and
button-down shirts.
I
really don’t recall many issues during the first decade of life that would
contribute to early gender experiences. My mother and father had some very
angry talks about me on the subject that indicated I was to be this little boy
and do little-boy things. It wasn’t difficult for me to repress the feelings I
had about being a little girl; my mother told me that I felt this way because I
liked girls so much and that I would soon begin to feel more like a little boy.
Being
named “Jr.” was a curse for me because my father felt I should be just as macho
as he. He absolutely abhorred my behavior. Is it any wonder, then, that I ended
my first decade living two distinct lives? I feared my father. He would pull
the belt off of his pants and use it with very little provocation. The net
result of this was to learn to adapt. In one life I lived in a world of fantasy
of what could or should be, and on
the other side, I lived a life of harsh reality. This made me pretty much of a loner, but it also allowed me to adopt a personal resolve to face the most challenging of issues and manage to overcome them.
DECADE 2 (YEARS 11-20)
Ah, the sounds of the gymnasium locker room, the smell of all the boys
getting ready to shower and dress for the next class come rushing back to me. I
was a year younger than most of the boys in my class. I admired how some of
them always seemed in control. They could rally folks around them, have others
follow their lead in everything they did. They could tell jokes, get good
grades, as well as do some of the meanest things to their peers. The locker
room, for me, was okay. Sid was one of those “special leader” types who
protected me when any of the others began to pick on me. It could be because my
body hair wasn’t growing like it did on everyone else or if I had some
difficulty with some of the physical exercises, things that others could do. He
told the other boys that it was due to my being a year younger. When my hair
did start coming in, no one noticed that I shaved it off. I didn’t want to look
like the other boys. I wanted 1o look like the girls—smooth, fresh, lovely,
cute. Even though I knew that I couldn’t, I made a sincere effort to look more
like them. I wanted to fit in the world that I was thrust into, no matter what
personal discomfort at being with boys rather than girls, and to measure up to
the physical demands expected of a boy my age. I relied on the lessons from the
first decade. I could deceive these boys and my teachers into believing that I
was a boy. I could adapt myself to be on the outside what I thought they wanted
me to be. This is how I was surviving my everyday life at home, so it was easy
to expand it here at the school.
I
still had a special separate life where I could be me. I wasn’t sure what me was. I felt that I wasn’t quite like everyone else. The
magazines and TV shows of the day (early to mid-1960s) really glamorized
smoking. Leaving a ring of red lipstick on a cigarette butt, or holding that
cigarette up with red painted nails and slender hands. Ah, that was glamorous
and sexy. I would go into the garage and smoke my mother’s cigarettes, Tareton. The commercial was of this beautiful woman with a
blackened eye stating that she would rather fight than switch brands. Now, that
was a nice combination of manliness and femininity. I would feel very feminine
when holding up that cigarette, sensuously blowing out the smoke, imagining the
red lips and nails.
Life
changed drastically when my father broke his back. We were forced to move into
the country where new responsibilities and demands were placed on each of us.
The arduous task of rebuilding the home, irrigating the desert to grow alfalfa,
digging fence posts, working the cattle and horses—all developed my body into
what a thirteen- to fourteen-year-old boy was supposed look like. I became
lean, and tall, not exceptionally muscular, but I had a lot of strength. That
first summer I had a job as a lifeguard for a swimming pool. Jerry and I would
ride our bikes the four or five miles to the pool and clean the pool prior to
opening. He was a year behind me in school but the same age. He was very well
developed, while I was this lean young man. I remember a swimmer named Woody,
who shaved his legs to allow for faster swimming. It prompted me to learn to
swim, for then I, too, could shave my legs. I could now appear in public
without fear or humiliation from this practice. I had to look more feminine. It
was exhilarating not to hide or live in a secret world. What pure joy it was to
do daily things without shame. Alas, the workload became too strenuous at home
and I had to give up the swimming pool job.
I
went back into hiding. Somehow, I knew that I was doing something wrong. I
struggled incessantly with why I felt that way. Why am I doing this when
no one else my age wants to do it? I didn’t see any other boy in school having
the same desires, or were they hiding like me, living
a secret life? Are there other people like me? I didn’t think so because I
would surely have heard any rumors to that effect in this small Southwestern
desert town. One day I heard about a soldier who had a sex change operation and
was now living his life as a woman. Christine Jorgensen became a part of my
imagination and lifelong dream. What if I could become a woman? Could I do it
now, while in my teens, and stop the male development of my body? I began
having this recurring dream. I dreamed of having breasts like other young girls
were developing. When I awoke from dreams, I would feel down my chest; oh no,
another dream and no breasts. Those dreams were so real! There were times when
I would run to the bathroom and look in the mirror to make sure. The disappointment and realization that I could never be like the
other girls in my class made for withdrawal into a private secret world.
My other recurring dream was in the form of prayer. Dear God, I would ask,
please make me whole, make me into a girl or into a boy, but make me whole.
I
found myself attracted to girls but not physically. I wanted to be like them,
look like them, be able to act like them—heck, I wanted to be one of
them! I dated a few times. There were some beautiful girls who really wanted to
be with me, and I wanted to be with them, but only to just hang out. I wanted
to learn all I could about them, live my life through them, and to know what it
was really like to be girl. My fantasy world only provided me with so much
input before the harsh reality hit me and it made me look at who I was. I felt
tremendous rejection within myself at this time. I didn’t think I was good enough
for anyone. I felt that I was “damaged” property I just didn’t have anything to
offer. My family didn’t have much money, and I was neither a scholar nor an
athlete.
One
clear memory occurred during my teenage years. It is an incident related to
gender presentation. I would put on mom’s bra when I went to the bathroom I was
taking a bath and had forgotten to lock the door. So, when it opened, I threw
the bra over my shoulder and it landed behind the old eagle claw bathtub. My
mother found it later. She looked at me squarely when she asked how it might
have gotten there. I, of course, maintained a deafening silence. Adolescence
was difficult for me. Whether it was the verbal and physical abuse from my
father or an inner desire to be someone different, I just don’t recall much
during this decade.
At
seventeen I enlisted in the navy. As soon as high school graduation was
complete, I was off to
After
a few months in the navy I realized that I couldn’t be the man I wanted to be.
Something inside prevented me from acting like other men. I wanted so much to
have these femme feelings go away. As I mentioned before, I wanted to be like
other guys. At the age of eighteen I volunteered for
After
my first tour of duty, I thought I’d look for others like me. My ship was home
based out of
DECADE 3 (YEARS 21-30)
At age twenty—one I was assigned to an aircraft carrier that was moored in
the Gulf of Aden during the
During
my time aboard ship, I was very discreet with my femme/ masculine
presentations. I would shave off all my body hair, trim my eye-brows, and
sometimes use clear polish for my nails. As a macho man, I would sometimes grow
a beard or a mustache. I truly thought I was living in my own world, unknown to
anyone else. A second-class petty officer told me one day to call him when I’ve
had my sex change. That came as a complete surprise. To me, that meant that
people knew about me and they just didn’t care. I had spent most of my time
alone and away from others, and that comment may not have been necessary.
Upon
my return home from the navy tour of duty, I married Becky I regret that I
couldn’t muster enough courage to tell her about my innermost feelings. I
wanted to break off the wedding plans, even though I had pushed for her to
marry me. I didn’t know how to stop the whole process without embarrassing me,
her, and our families. A few weeks after taking our marriage vows, I had all
these feelings, desires to feminize again. I couldn’t stop them and perhaps,
more important, I didn’t want to. One day my mother came to the house unexpectedly
While Becky was at work, I had just polished my nails. I almost died when she
knocked on the door. For the whole time that she was there I kept my nails
hidden. She looked at me quizzically, but didn’t say anything. The experience
was both a frightening and an exhilarating moment, of nearly getting “caught.”
What if I had been caught and my gender conflict had been out in the open, in
what ways would my life have changed? Would such exposure
have allowed me to live openly that which I had kept secret all my life?
Or would I become a victim of humiliation to all?
One
time, my wife did her own nails and she offered to paint nail lacquer on one of
my hands, too. It was a pivotal point in my life. Later that night I awoke,
took a shower, shaved all my body hair, and applied makeup before going back to
bed. Becky woke up and asked me where I had been. Crying, I told her I took a
shower and feminized my body It was then that we
talked about the inner me for the first time; about how I felt inside. Finally,
I was able to share my secret with someone close, and it opened many
doors. I went to the university library and looked for anything related to what
I was feeling, but I was not successful. I had no idea what the terminology was
or how to search for anything about the subject. I knew for certain that I
wasn’t gay.
During
college I enrolled in Army ROTC and, upon graduation, accepted a commission in
the Finance Corps of the army. The Finance Officer Basic Course was a
tremendous experience. I got instant recognition as a second lieutenant and was
given my own private sleeping quarters. This enabled me to feminize without
fear of discovery. To ensure to my peers that I “was a man,” I would act more
macho than most of them. However, I still couldn’t be a man. I could look,
walk, and talk like a man, but I definitely felt that I was not like other men.
Knowing within myself that I could never change being a man, I tried time and
time again to “be a man” and couldn’t. Now that I was back in the military; I
had to work much harder at disguising this inner me. I had developed tricks to
hide my femme side. I had to conform to what all those around me considered a
man to be: an army officer, a father, a husband. I couldn’t shake my desire to
be feminine. It was like an obsessive- compulsive thing. My innermost feelings
would begin, much like the beating of a drum, and it would be intense, and
overwhelming. All was quiet within my mind when the “drum beating” stopped.
Only by feminizing myse1f even partially, would these intense feelings stop. At
its peak, I would finally give in to this emotion and “take action.” This
evoked a new set of emotions that would take over. I felt guilt, fear, and
shame. In the quiet of my mind I would doubt my sanity; reasons for living, and
an inability to control my inner feelings. I felt terribly inadequate and
inferior. I asked God, the “why me?” routine. This led to redoubling my efforts
to be “right” and “normal.” During these periods I was highly productive. I
could focus on any task and do it well. However, the drums of my femininity
returned, would reach a crescendo, and the cycle would begin again.
DECADE 4 (YEARS 31-40)
Having been married twice by the age of thirty, I was about to marry for a
third time. This time I went to several psychiatrists to get help with my
gender conflict. Each of them had their own idea of what I should be. One
suggested that I was fundamentally gay. Another believed that the conflict was
due to an “abused childhood.” Still another said that my grandmother’s
“sweetness” during childhood was a cause of my gender troubles.
By
this time, I had read a few books on my own and had even visited with a
physician who performed the sex change operation. I was living in
In
the early years of this decade I was getting hormone treatments. These were
illegally obtained because I feared that if the military found out I would be
dishonorably discharged. The hormones over the last ten years of my career
definitely affected my ability to meet the military physical fitness standards.
I almost didn’t make it a couple of times. I had to stoop a little and pull my
shoulders in so that my breasts would not show. Daily life was a challenge to
physically be a man and an army officer. There was always present the constant
fear of discovery. If people suspected anything about my feminization, they
never mentioned it directly. My home life was becoming very hard. My wife found
me physically repulsive and asked that I sleep in pajamas to keep her from
seeing my body. While we slept in the same bed, we didn’t touch.
It
was during this time that I made some key decisions. I would retire and leave
my wonderful family. I would live alone and learn how to be me. I had achieved
a degree of success in the military became a field-grade officer, and was being
considered for a promotion, transfer to another part of the country, and would
have a new set of responsibilities. I decided not accept promotion and
transfer. I preferred to stay with the transgender friends and acquaintances
that I had met in
DECADE 5 (YEARS 41-50)
This was the decade of awakening, the decade of experiencing life. Upon
retirement from the military, I moved out of my family home and began to live
life alone. I was lonely and occasionally prone to some serious crying jags.
However, this was a period of positive growth. I slept alone, and there was no
one to find me repulsive and unlovable. I no longer lived in a constant state
of rejection. The decision to give up everything I had was overwhelming and
brought with it major consequences. I gave up my home, my family, and my
career. I was starting off fresh. A clean slate. I had
no money, no job, no support network, and only a few friends. This is when I
found out what being alone truly meant.
Even
before my retirement, I experienced the first phase of my gender reassignment,
an orchiectomy. I remember that it was Mother’s Day and this was a gift
to myself I had finally stopped the source of the “bad hormones” that had been
coursing through my body. Now I would see the real me develop over the course
of the next several months. I wished that I could’ve afforded to have the
complete sexual reassignment surgery then. The recurring dream of just
knowing I was a woman was still with me. All my life I had dreamed that I was a
female, and upon awakening I would run my hand down my body. First the hand
would pass over my budding breast and I would smile and know it was true, but
then my hand would continue to the genital area and discover that I was just
deluding myself I wasn’t really a woman. I was just a velveteen rabbit. I was a
“wannabe.” When I awoke, I would sit up and say “Oh shit” and begin my day.
I
began my transition with Tiffany. We both retired from the military at the same
time and lived together for a short period while attempting to get a business
started. I was overdosing on hormones, and she was experiencing the loss of a
dear friend. Both of us were too depressed to get the business off the ground.
I moved on, without clear purpose, but I did cut back on the hormonal intake so
at least I wasn’t suicidal and totally depressed anymore.
Transition
in the normal sense wasn’t for me. As I saw it, it was a big lie to present
myself as a woman when I wasn’t. I didn’t get a big thrill out of wearing
feminine clothing. Rather I wanted to be. I wanted to be the woman I
knew I was. This was a physical desire, not a desire to pretend I am a woman.
My outer presentation was less important than to be true to myself then I could
dress appropriately. In effect, I did the transition in reverse: have the
surgery first, then dress and live accordingly. If I couldn’t get a job and
live as Paula, I would work as Paul. Who cares what is between my legs except
me? I had a forty-one-year history of being a male. I can’t turn that away and
create a false past. I decided that I am neither a man nor a woman. I am me. If
I must label myself, I am a transsexual woman, a spiritual being having a human
experience.
I
focused on creating a business as a way to deal with all the stresses of my
life. I took the concept to several states in the Southwest. I tried to forget
that I was neither gender and just worked at the survival skills. I needed to
eat, sleep, and make enough money to support my estranged family. I was honest
with myself during this two-year period, though. I was in a disguise for the
express purpose of creating work or at least a life where I could support
myself while going through transition. I just nearly didn’t make it. Once
again, I couldn’t make a success of the business venture. I was considered too
passionate, too focused. I didn’t bother to tell anyone that this was my life
for the moment, that there was nothing else for me, that
I had to make this work or die. One person during this time told his girlfriend
that I was on the edge and a person to be wary of. His making that comment
brought me to a realization that I was on the edge and had no idea of how to
move away from it. I returned home and asked to live in the guest room until I
could find employment and support myself again. The children were ecstatic.
They had always given me unconditional love and valued me being in the house
again. Of course I presented as Paul, and that meant my wife didn’t have to
face the embarrassment of having others know and be aware of me or my
transition.
I
found a job as a traveling consultant, which suited me just fine. My spouse
even fronted me the funds to do what needed to be done. My life was on track
again, but as a man and not as the woman I had wanted to be. The consulting
firm went out of business while I was on a job site in
that we
should get divorced. That would allow her to move forward with her life. I
allowed myself to be taken advantage of during the proceedings. I felt I owed
her because I had caused her to lose the most valuable years of her life. My
daughters still provided me with unconditional love and are unafraid of showing
me affection. Two days after the divorce was final, I had a penectomy
and altered how I went to the restroom. After healing from the surgery, I had
the final episode of the recurring dream. The one of waking as a woman and
running my hand down my body and just knowing that I was real and not the
velveteen rabbit after all. Finally, I was the woman I wanted to be for most of
my life.
The
next year was a struggle for me. I had my surgery and without the experience of
the Real Life Test. I refused to live my life in masculine presentation again.
I lived in fear of being caught in a women’s restroom or of being labeled a
pervert by someone with no knowledge or education concerning gender conflict.
So I transitioned after surgery; and I stayed with a friend who was very
supportive. She even had romantic desires toward me both before and after the
transition. It meant that I could still have a relationship. But that isn’t
where I wanted to be. I didn’t want to share my life, with her, at this point
in time. I just didn’t love her in a romantic way. Now, I was working in my
chosen role as Paula. I was open as a transsexual and giving lectures at
several Midwestern universities. I had accomplished all I set out to do. I was
a professional woman working at a big-ten university as a financial analyst. My
dream became a reality, at last.
While
giving a lecture at an
I’m
no longer fearful or apprehensive about life, but I wonder which position I
want to accept, where do I want to go next, or what do
I really want to do. I have about given up on a relationship. Lesbian women
tend to want a real woman, and I don’t want to involve myself with a man. I
suppose I’ll continue to look for that one special person, male, female, third
gender, or no gender, who will allow me to love them or at least share with
them life’s daily routines and events—the happiness, the sadness, the joy, and
the tribulation. Life for me during this decade has been exceptionally
rewarding. If nothing else, I have learned to live with myself and have worked
toward being of benefit to others.
I’m
at the fifty-year mark, and I reflect on what I would like to have said at my
memorial service. I would want people to know that I made a positive impact on
others; that they have the strength within to succeed, not just survive; that I
once had a kind word for some people at just the right instant when it was
needed; that I was a good influence on how they behaved toward others. I could
only dream that members of my family would stand and say they were proud of me,
that I lived by my convictions, and that I brought about a positive glow and
direction to them.
Most
important, I want to be remembered for being a person, one who would smile at
you on the street. A person who would not turn away from her
fellow man during a time of need. Just a spiritual
being having a human experience. As a friend of mine is wont to say,
“Warm F1o’